Our Team

Suzette Smith, founder

Suzette believes you have to love the body you live in. And she’s proved that by focusing on total wellness of body and mind you can truly age gracefully. At 62 years old, she’s proving it. 

Suzette was born in Chingola, Zambia and trained in Europe and New York City to become a professional dancer. She danced across Europe and later founded her own ballroom dance company, Sophisticated Steps, in New York City. She spent a decade working for the Board of Education in NYC teaching dance and choreography, and collaborated with City Center to develop dance programs in schools citywide. She was recognized as an award-winning choreographer for her work at the Professional Performing Arts School.

After fighting and surviving breast cancer in 1995, she embarked on a journey of healing, becoming a Reiki and Transformational Breath practitioner, as well as studying the healing art of Thai Yoga Massage in Thailand.  She is deeply grateful to have found Pilates as the perfect venue to synthesize her vast knowledge of the body, her innovative teaching expertise and her profound healing practices. 

Suzette received her Pilates training at the prestigious Kane School of Core Integration in New York City and her national certification through the Pilates Method Alliance. Suzette is a Barre instructor, as well as a Zumba and Nia instructor. She has her Master of Education degree with a focus on dance from Cambridge College in Cambridge, MA. 

Suzette established Shelter Island Pilates & Barre in 2004 where she now lives year-round and specializes in body alignment, postural assessment & correction, and proper mechanics. She is inspired to create a nurturing and restorative fitness environment, and her studio and staff are expressions of the values she and her business embody: expert knowledge, commitment to excellence, and customized care. 

Nicole Silver began her movement career as a professional contemporary dancer. She earned her BFA in Dance from the Boston Conservatory before moving to New York City, where she received her Pilates certification in 2013. Since then, Nicole has caught the travel bug and has taught Pilates in luxury resorts across the world, including Amanyara, COMO Shambhala Estate Bali, and COMO Parrot Cay. Nicole holds comprehensive Pilates certifications from BASI Pilates and Erika Bloom Pilates, as well as a 200-hour yoga teacher training certificate from YogaWorks. She is a supportive teacher, and loves teaching clients of all ages and abilities. Her classes are challenging with a focus on precision and technique. 

Kelly Sheppard started her career in Charleston, South Carolina, in the early 2000s. The moment she was introduced to Pilates mat work, she felt an instant connection to the method. Pilates is a mind-body connection that teaches you to move with purpose. Kelly received her full 600-hour comprehensive certification in Charleston. A forever student who loves to learn and grow, she has continued her education with courses that support her Pilates instructor journey: a cadaver anatomy course for orthopedic injuries, Power Pilates, Stretchfit and Anthony Lett, Pink Ribbon Program, Club Pilates Bridge Program, Da Vinci Board, and Barre workshops. Kelly now resides with her family in Sag Harbor and happy to call the area home.

Mary Henley is a former professional ballet dancer/dance teacher whose keen interest in making movement make sense led her to Pilates. She received her Pilates certification in 2010 and has taught people from all walks of life. She holds a comprehensive certification from BASI Pilates with additional licenses and certifications from Fletcher Pilates, Progressing Ballet Technique, and Boston Ballets Adaptive Dance Teacher Training.

Born and raised in Northern Virginia, Mary trained at the Washington School of Ballet and danced professionally with the Louisville Ballet, Chicago City Ballet, and with several regional companies in the DC, MD and VA areas. In 2018 Mary and her family moved to Australia where she continued to teach both dance and Pilates in Canberra and in regional New South Wales. She is an enthusiastic and supportive teacher who enjoys bringing her sense of humor and love of teaching to her classes and clients. Mary is delighted to be joining the team at Shelter Island Pilates and Barre.

Andrea Milnik began her fitness journey by striving for strength in mind, body, and soul. She has an innovative teaching style, sequencing to build strength, stability, and agility in a healthy and effective way.  She is always learning new ways to incorporate positive fitness techniques to keep your fitness journey fun and interesting.

Starting out in nursing school, with a thirst for knowledge about how the human body operates, Andrea decided to take a more holistic approach to help people live a healthy lifestyle. She is a certified Pilates, yoga, aerial, and barre instructor with a martial arts background.  Teaching for over 20 years, she loves what she does and strives to be better through each and every experience!